Saturday, March 13, 2010

SOA's beginning to feel a lot like CORBA

If you ever visit my garage, you'll find a couple of book shelves out there. On the shelves are an array of computer books, on all sorts of topics. I'll sometimes buy books at garage sales, at the GoodWill store, or especially off Amazon from the 'used' section. Most of the books I buy are cheap-- I'll buy 2 or 3 books off Amazon for a few bucks each plus shipping. I like books better than online reading because I can mark them up and take them with me wherever I go. (Sorry, a Kindle just doesn't seem the same. I ease my conscience by telling myself I'm buying used, so I'm not really causing any new trees to be felled.) A few of the books I've bought this way are terrible, but most have at least a few good chapters and a couple have been really good. I'm able to get more perspectives on a topic by buying in quantity rather than spending more money for quality. (By the way, I keep a few books inside the house-- any 'high dollar' new books, or any books that have my name inside them for some reason. By keeping only a subset of my books inside the house, I've found my married life is much happier!) Among my 'outside' books you'll find a couple of volumes on CORBA.

We still use CORBA in places where I work. Mostly we make use of the 'Naming Service' and the data-marshalling capabilities (which we find to be very performant, BTW). The 'Naming Service' is a sort of registry for CORBA services. When my service comes up, it uses a well-known (that is, hard-coded and shared by other services) address to reach out to the Naming Service. My service then registers itself with the Naming Service by supplying a name for itself and the address of the machine it's running on. (So my service might pick the name /Persistence/Sharding/ShardLocator.) Then whenever a client wants to use my ShardLocator service, it uses the same well-known address to get to the Naming Service, and it asks it where it can find /Persistence/Sharding/ShardLocator. The Naming Service will pick either my service or another machine that hosts this service and tells the client that's where the service can be found. When my service shuts down, it is obligated to un-register with the Naming Service so the registry in theory contains only 'live' service instances. (Note to newbies: This is done so clients don't have to hard-code the location of servers they need to talk to. Then when a machine fails or you add a new server instance, it's easier.)

If I look through one of my ancient CORBA books, I see great tales of what CORBA should be used for. There are distributed transactions, mechanisms for dynamically finding and invoking methods, a query mechanism, etc. etc. But as I said, we make use of only a few simple services. I think this is common-- I bet most people that still use CORBA only use a few parts of the whole spec.

Lately, I've been working on a team charged with architecting a sizeable new greenfield application. We're considering different SOA components to use-- an ESB, an orchestration engine, maybe some other parts. If you look at SOA suites offered by big vendors, you'll see quite a laundry list of components-- Governance helpers, Business Rules Engines, Complex event processing, etc. (By the way, the open source guys offer these too.) But I'm not sure we'll be using all that stuff, probably just the parts we really need. The whole thing is beginning to feel vaguely like CORBA.

CORBA and SOA are also similar in that they were largely spec-driven efforts that tried to answer all the problems the industry was trying to solve. I think it's widely accepted that the reason they didn't realise full potential was that the specs grew too complicated (WS-* anyone?) and the vendor implementations didn't really interoperate.

It's been over a year now since a prominent industry analyst proclaimed "SOA is Dead". (Google that one, you'll find plenty.) So it looks to me like SOA has roughly followed the same lifecycle CORBA did:

CORBA was lively from roughly 1990 - 2000
SOA was lively from roughly 2000 - 2010

Cloud, to me, is a lot like SOA re-packaged with some machine requisition thrown in.

I'm left pondering a few questions:
- How will we look back at SOA a few years from now?
- Will we have another tech stack arise for the next decade? What will it be?


Thanks for reading, and Happy Coding!

20 comments:

marry said...

Blogs are so informative where we get lots of information on any topic. Nice job keep it up!!
_____________________________

Dissertation Projects

Dissertation Help said...

I recently came across your blog and have been reading along. I don't know what to say except that I have enjoyed reading. Nice blog.I will keep visiting this blog very often.
Dissertation Help | Custom Dissertation

Aria Kerry said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
preety said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Alice Thomas said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
T├╝pbebek said...

I am happy to find this very useful for me, as it contains lot of information. I always prefer to read the quality content
ada..

bad credit said...

Great topic, I am grateful for this blog. I want to follow you, great blog.

shakeology said...

What I want to know is why you didnt think to include the other side of this issue? There are so many things that youre missing here that I dont see how you could actually form an intelligent opinion on the subject. Its like you didnt even consider that there me be another side here. Im kind of disappointed.

marven said...

There are so many things that your missing here that , logo design , I like it .

James Kimber said...

Excellent post, fantastic job i like it.

Topics For College Essay
Example Of A College Essay
Academic Writing
APA format term paper
custom term papers writing
term paper writing
how to write a term paper
term paper help
economics term paper
term paper subjects
english term paper
term paper formats
finance term paper
term papers online
health term paper
custom term papers writing
culture term paper

James Kimber said...

The above post is awesome I found your blog via Google and it is about my research academic writing strive to maintain the highest level of customer satisfaction.

college admission essay examples are great it is very use full information for students specially for those students who searching for college entry essays.

academic writing services
topics for argumentative essay
argumentative essay topics
argumentative topics
classification essay
topics for college essay
topics for compare and contrast essay
compare and contrast essay
good essay questions
essay on love
Narrative essay format
Personal narrative essay format
cause and effect essay

Cheap Logo Design said...

This is one of the highly informatics and attractive blogs that has not only educated also informed me in a very effective manner. There are very few blog like this one I have read.

food recipes said...

I'm so excited to find your blog, I couldn't find so worthy information on this matter. This is perfect job, your post is just what I was looking for!

professional research paper writing services said...

We also use COBRA in our work, what will be next?

drug test cocaine said...

Sta bre nije umetnost. Preradi ti nesto pa imaj 4 mil.pregleda. Corba zakon

bookmarking said...

I really enjoy the article. It proved to be really useful for me and I am sure to all the followers here! Keep blogging.


Birthday Gifts
Unique Gifts
Anniversary Gifts
gift ideas

bookmarking said...

I really enjoy the article. It proved to be really useful for me and I am sure to all the followers here! Keep blogging.


Birthday Gifts
Unique Gifts
Anniversary Gifts
gift ideas

marven said...

I'm so excited to find your blog, I couldn't find so worthy information on this matter. This is perfect job, your post is just what I was looking for,wireless internet .

marven said...

I like that Armed America stuff! Two wrongs don't make a right.wifi in the usa .

Beginner Ski Resorts said...

it is a great artecial to learn something frome it i highly apresiate tis article